Specific and, whenever possible, quantifiable
Is the evidence clearly indicative of the intended outcome/result?
| -
“Survey data (see supplemental doc #1) indicates that 90% of candidates (n=67) said they were satisfied with the advising on licensure requirements they received in 2017.” (Scale: Satisfied, somewhat satisfied, somewhat dissatisfied, dissatisfied)
|
-
“Many candidates have expressed satisfaction with advising.”
|
Measured by multiple sources
Do multiple sources of evidence corroborate or reinforce the claim? Are there discrepancies that need to be addressed?
| -
Multiple surveys
-
SO-collected data and state collected data
-
Data on the same outcome from multiple stakeholder groups
-
Quantitative and qualitative data points related to the same outcome/result
| -
Evidence of an outcome/result is limited to data from a single data point, single source of evidence, or single stakeholder group.
|
Interpreted
Is the evidence written in a way that makes the conclusion clear to the reader? Would multiple different readers reach the same conclusion?
| -
Shares the data point(s) and additional context to explain the takeaway
| -
Shares the data point(s) without additional context
|
|