For cross-verification contributions, it was agreed that the group would ordinarily only review cross-checks for proposals that appear promising.
When considering cross-check contributions, it was agreed that, to the extent feasible, the following data should be collected:
-
Subject (including document number).
-
Whether common conditions were followed.
-
Whether the results are complete.
-
Whether the results match those reported by the contributor (within reasonable limits, such as minor compiler/platform differences).
-
Whether the contributor studied the algorithm and software closely and has demonstrated adequate knowledge of the technology.
-
Whether the contributor independently implemented the proposed technology feature, or at least compiled the software themselves.
-
Any special comments and observations made by the cross-check contributor.
Dostları ilə paylaş: |
