Infso-2008-00093-00-02-en-rev-01

Compliance rate (IND 3/5)	48%	52%	68%	66%
Average % (IND 2/4/6)		52.56%	53.02%	28.51%	29.72%	67.63%	69.58%

A) Reasons given by Member State for failure to achieve the proportions

1. Majority proportion of European works (Article 4)

Subject matter of the channel:

Film 4, Film Four Weekly, Kiss, Kerrang, XXX TV, Sky Movies Comedy, Sky Movies Action/Thriller, Sky Box Office, 18 Plus Movies, Sky Movies Premier, E!, E! Entertainment (France), E! Entertainment UK, E! Entertainment (Italy), Front Row, ITV4, Playboy, Playboy TV, Playboy One, Playboy (France), Zone Romantica, ABC 1, Disney Cinemagic, Disney Channel, VH1 Europe Classics, VH1 Export, VH1 Polska, MTV Norway, MTV Base, MTV Europe (North), VH1 Classic, MTV Finland, MTV (Ireland), MTV UK, MTV Portugal, MTV Nordic (Sweden), VH1, Viva Polska.

When the channel commenced broadcasting:

Baby TV, Life TV, REN TV (Baltic version), Unity TV, Trade.TV, Kanal 4, Sumo TV, Ontv, Comedy Central Polska.

Difficulty in finding European programmes or finding European programmes at competitive prices:

Nickelodeon Europe, Nickelodeon Scandinavia, Nickelodeon France, AXN (Italy), AXN Crime, AXN Sci Fi, AXN, AXN (Germany, Switzerland), 100% Babes, Sky One, Sky Two, CNBC Europe, CNBC Europe (Central), Discovery HD, Discovery Channel (UK), Discovery HD Europe, Discovery Channel France, Discovery Science UK, Discovery Civilisation Middle East, Discovery Travel & Living Italy, Discovery Channel Nordic, Discovery Channel (Italy), Discovery Channel (Benelux), Discovery (Central & Eastern Europe), Discovery (Middle East, Africa and Turkey), Discovery Science Italy, ACTIONMAX, Movies4Men, Trouble, Living TV, f/x Channel, FX+, DoveVision TV, National Geographic, Wild, National Geographic Benelux, National Geographic CE, National Geographic HD, Nicktoons, Nicktoons TV, Nickelodeon, Nickelodeon (Eire), Paramount Comedy, Paramount Comedy Ireland, The Voice TV (Norway), The Voice TV (Sweden), Sci Fi Channel Europe, Sci Fi TV, Hallmark Entertainment UK, Hallmark Channel Italy, Hallmark Channel (CZ), Hallmark Channel (Central), Hallmark Channel (Benelux), Hallmark Channel (Sc), History Channel HD. Crime & Investigation, The Biography Channel, The History Channel, Toon Disney Scandinavia, Cartoon Network Too, Boomerang (German), Boomerang (Pan-European), TCM (Germany), Cartoon Network (EMEA), Boomerang (Italian), Cartoon Network/Turner, Boomerang (Spain), Toonami, Boomerang (French), Cartoon Network (Norway), Cartoon Network (French), TCM2, TCM Pan-European, Cartoon Network (Spain), TCM (Turner Classic Movies), TCM (French language), Cartoon Network (Italy), CN’s Boomerang, TCM (Spanish language), Cartoon Network UK, Cartoon Network (Germany), ZTV Norway, 3+, TV3 Denmark, TV3 Sweden, TV3 Norway, Zone Europa, Zone Thriller, Zone Reality Extra, Zone Reality (UK), Zone Reality +1, Zone Horror, Zone Reality (EMEA 2), Zone Fantasy, Zone Horror (Netherlands), Zone Reality, Zone Club (Hungary), Movies 24, Movies 24 +.

Subsidiaries of companies based in non-member countries broadcasting programmes mostly from their stock or from non-member distributors:

ABC 1, Disney Cinemagic, Disney Channel, Hustler TV UK, EWTN, Select Kino.

2. Minimum proportion of European works by independent producers (Article 5)

When the channel commenced broadcasting:

Baby Channel, Rockworld, My Channel, Islam Channel.

Difficulty in finding cost-competitive independent European producers:

The Disney Channel Scandinavia, Playhouse Disney Scandinavia, Disney Channel Middle East, 3+ (Baltics), ZTV, Viasat Explorer, Viasat History, TV6, MUTV, Discovery Historia, Discovery Real Time France, Sky Venue, The Business Channel, Turn on TV, Muslim TV Ahmadiyya International.