Omg issue Number

Disposition: Resolved

OMG Issue No: 11528

Title: Issue 11528: Section 6/6.3

Source:

UFRGS - DELET (WILSON PARDI JUNIOR, [e-mail])

Summary:

In the first paragraph of sub-section 6.3.1 it is written "These are shown by the RTEM package in Figure 6.4, and the cluster of four AnalysisModelling packages, respectively". However, I see only three packages under the MARTE analysis model: GQAM, SAM, and PAM. Also I don't see the TCRM package (by the way, I presume that the RTEM and RTEMoCC are the same packages). Am I wrong at my assumptions?

Resolution:

At the beginning, the Analysis package aims including an additional package dedicated to WCET analysis. At the end, this purpose was not achieved. So, this package contains at last only 3 packages => text need to be revised as described in the next section.

In general, the figure 6.4 reflects correctly the current architecture of the MARTE extensions but the text put on top of this figure needs to be updated to take into account the final name of the package as described in the figure.

Revised Text:

Change the text of the first paragraph of section 6.3.1 (on page12 and 13):

Previous text:

“The profile is structured around two concerns, one to model the features of real-time and embedded systems and the other to annotate application models so as to support analysis of system properties. These are shown by the RTEM package in Figure 6.4, and the cluster of four “AnalysisModeling” packages, respectively. These two major parts share common concerns with describing time and the use of concurrent resources, which are contained in the shared package TCRM. Finally the “AnalysisModeling” features are broken into a foundational generic part in the package GQAM, and three packages for specific analysis domains, as shown. These first three domains are entirely concerned with time, however the profile structure allows for adding additional analysis domains, such as power consumption, memory use or reliability. It is the intention to encourage modular sub profiles like the three “AnalysisModeling” packages, for such domains.”

New text:

“The profile is structured around two main concerns, one to model the features of real-time and embedded systems and the other to annotate application models so as to support analysis of system properties. These are shown by the RTEM package named “MARTE design model” in Figure 6.4, and the cluster of three packages gathered in the package named “MARTE analysis model”, respectively. These two major parts share common concerns with describing time and the use of concurrent resources, which are contained in the shared package named “MARTE foundations”. Finally the “AnalysisModeling” features are broken into a foundational generic part in the package GQAM, and two packages for specific analysis domains, as shown. These first two specific analysis domains are entirely concerned with time, however the profile structure allows for adding additional analysis domains, such as power consumption, memory use or reliability. It is the intention to encourage modular sub profiles like the two analysis packages, for such domains.”

Disposition: Resolved

Disposition: Resolved

OMG Issue No: 11529

Title: Issue 11529: Section 6/6.4

Source:

UFRGS - DELET (WILSON PARDI JUNIOR, [e-mail])

Summary:

There a lot of spelling errors in the section 6.4.1:

- "...; chapter 0, General Component Model, introdces a general componenet model suitable for RTES." should be rewritten as "...; chapter 11, General Component Model, introduces a general component model suitable for RTES."

- "..., chapter 13, RTE Model of Compuation and Communication, ..." should be rewritten as "..., chapter 13, RTE Model of Computation and Communication, ..."

- "It does not intend to define new analmysis technologies, but to define the information required for annotation models on whoch external analysis techniques may be applied." should be rewritten as "It does not intend to define new analysis technologies, but to define the information required for annotation models on which external analysis techniques may be applied."

- "..., specializes the generic framework for performaing schedulability analysis, whereas ..." should be rewritten as "..., specializes the generic framework for performing schedulability analysis, whereas ..."

Resolution:

Do editiorial change as suggested.

Revised Text:

In section 6.4.1:

- "...; chapter 0, General Component Model, introdces a general componenet model suitable for RTES." should be rewritten as "...; chapter 11, General Component Model, introduces a general component model suitable for RTES."

- "..., chapter 13, RTE Model of Compuation and Communication, ..." should be rewritten as "..., chapter 13, RTE Model of Computation and Communication, ..."

- "It does not intend to define new analmysis technologies, but to define the information required for annotation models on whoch external analysis techniques may be applied." should be rewritten as "It does not intend to define new analysis technologies, but to define the information required for annotation models on which external analysis techniques may be applied."

- "..., specializes the generic framework for performaing schedulability analysis, whereas ..." should be rewritten as "..., specializes the generic framework for performing schedulability analysis, whereas ..."

Disposition: Resolved

Disposition: Resolved

OMG Issue No: 11530

Title: Issue 11530: first sentence of sub-section 6.4.2

Source:

UFRGS - DELET (WILSON PARDI JUNIOR, [e-mail])

Summary:

The first sentence of sub-section 6.4.2 says: "Each extensions proposed by MARTE have been conflated around one main concerns and detailed in separate chapters: chapter 7 to chapter 18 and Annex E." I wonder if you mean "...chapter 7 to chapter 17 and Annex F." since there isn't a chapter 18, and Annex F is cited on the next paragraph.

Resolution:

Yes, the text should refer to chapter 7 to chapter 17 and Annex F. see next proposed resolution.

Revised Text:

In section 6.4.2, first paragraph, first sentence, replace: "Each extensions proposed by MARTE have been conflated around one main concerns and detailed in separate chapters: chapter 7 to chapter 18 and Annex E." by "Each extensions proposed by MARTE have been conflated around one main concerns and detailed in separate chapters: chapter 7 to chapter 17 and Annex F."

Disposition: Resolved