Organisation internationale de normalisation

25.4Action Points

26Multimedia Service Platform Architecture (23006-1)

26.1Topics

26.1.1ISO/IEC 23006-1 Architecture and technologies

26.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source	Disposition
MPEG-M	m18729	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 23006-1 [2nd Edition]	SC 29 Secretariat	Noted.
MPEG-M	m19333	Comments on the current MPEG-M specification	Victor Rodriguez-Doncel, Jaime Delgado	Accepted (N11754, N11756, N11758, N11760)
MPEG-M	m19407	Request for providing of use cases for MPEG-M	Kyoungro Yoon, Min-Uk Kim (Konkuk University), Seok-Pil Lee, Tae-Beom Lim, Kyung Won Kim, Yun Ju Lee, Jae Won Moon (KETI)	Accepted (N11754)
MPEG-M	m19411	Comment on AIT protocols based on Sensory Information	Choi, Lee, Jang, Park	Noted

26.3Summary of discussions

M18729 No comments.

M19333 Several comments on MPEG-M standards, Part 1, 2, 4 and 5

• 
  On the XML Schemata availability.
  
• 
  On the editor's notes
  
• 
  On the harmonization of the introductory clauses
  
• 
  On the Search Services
  
• 
  On the Services on Licences
  
• 
  On the Speech Recognition Service
  
• 
  Acronyms and terminology
  
• 
  On the formality of the API definition
  
• 
  On the orchestrator
  
• 
  Examples in Part 5
  

M19407 Proposed example usage scenario of MPEG-M

M19411 This contribution analyzed the use of MPEG-V together with MPEG-M.

26.4Action Points

27MXM API (23006-2)

27.1Topics

27.1.1ISO/IEC 23006-2 MXM API

27.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-M	m18730	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 23006-2 [2nd Edition]	SC 29 Secretariat	Accepted (N11755)

27.3Summary of discussions

M18730 Spain made comments. All resolved successfully.

27.4Action Points

28MSP Elementary Services (23006-4)

28.1Topics

28.1.1ISO/IEC 23006-4 MXM Protocols

28.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-M	m18731	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 23006-4 [2nd Edition]	SC 29 Secretariat	Accepted (N11757)
MPEG-M	m19239	Austrian NB comments on MPEG-M Part 4	Michael Grafl, Christian Timmerer, (on behalf of ANB)	Accepted (N11757)
MPEG-M	m19241	Editor's Input on 2nd edition CD of MPEG-M Part 4	Michael Grafl, (on behalf of the editors)	Accepted (N11758)

28.3Summary of discussions

M18731 Italy and Spain made comments. All resolved successfully.

M19239 Austria mad comments. All resolved successfully.

M19241 Editorial changes.

28.4Action Points

29MSP Service Aggregation (23006-5)

29.1Topics

29.1.1ISO/IEC 23006-5 MSP Service Aggregation

29.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-M	m18732	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC CD 23006-5	SC 29 Secretariat	Accepted (N11759)
MPEG-M	m19242	Austrian NB comments on MPEG-M Part 5	Michael Grafl, Christian Timmerer, (on behalf of ANB)	Accepted (N11759)
MPEG-M	m19243	Editor's Input on CD of MPEG-M Part 5	Michael Grafl, (on behalf of the editors)	Accepted (N11760)

29.3Summary of discussions

M18732 Spain made comments. All resolved successfully.

M19242 Austria made comments. All resolved successfully.

M19243 Editorial changes.

29.4Action Points

30Richmedia UI Widgets (23007-1)

30.1Topics

30.1.1Package, Delivery and Presentation of Widgets

30.1.2Communication

30.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-U	m18722	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC 23007-1:2010/PDAM 1	SC 29 Secretariat	Accepted (N11762)
MPEG-U	m18944	MPEG-U Widget Manager Interoperability and Capabilities Exchange	Jean-Claude Dufourd, Cyril Concolato, Jean Le Feuvre, Kyungmo Park, Jaeyeon Song	Accepted (N11763)

30.3Summary of discussions

M18722: One negative vote with comments (n18944) from France.

M18944: Proposing four extensions:

• 
  An identification of MPEG-U Widget Manager by means of a specific service. Question is does it need to be known at the UPnP level, or is it opaque to the network level? It is believed to be opaque.
  
• 
  A way for authors to express the component migration policy (activationTarget attribute)
  
• 
  A message for widget manager capabilities discovery. Details of capabilities are expressed in another language (e.g. MPEG-21 DIA). It is felt that it is not at the MPEG-U level to decide on the exact format. A Mime type may be needed (additional parameter in the message).
  
• 
  An element to group alternative components and factorize attributes such as activateTrigger.
  

30.4Action Points

31Advanced User Interaction Interface (23007-2)

31.1Topics

31.1.1Advanced User Interaction Interface

31.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-U	m19218	Proposed requirements, use cases and mechanism to support AUI interfaces	Seong Yong Lim, Injae Lee, Jihun Cha, Youngkwon Lim,	Accepted (N11765,N11781, N11836,N11837)

31.3Summary of discussions

M19218: The contribution presents the problem of accessing user interface events on different OS or on different devices. It shows that similar problems are being dealt with by WAC and W3C DAP. It also presents some requirements and use cases. It describes some semantic interpretation of low level interaction (line, rectangle, … and skeleton events), and combination of them.

The requirements may need to be discussed with requirements.

The events and semantic interpretation seem to be out-of-scope of MPEG-V but this needs to be cheked.

The use of these events in the scene can be done:

• 
  In LASeR, by using ExternalSensorEvents (see TuC)
  
• 
  In MPEG-U, because the structure of the schema for these events is complex, it is not straightforward to use them (see contribution at Geneva meeting). Contributions are welcome.
  

The contribution is accepted and its text will go in the WD. It is probably time to move to CD and request subdivision. Responses will come in July (3 months ballot for CD) and then because of the DIS ballot (5 months + 2 weeks) means standard in 2012.

31.4Action Points

32MPEG-U Conformance and Ref. SW (23007-3)

32.1Topics

32.1.1Conformance and Reference Software

32.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-U	m18708	Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC FCD 23007-3	SC 29 Secretariat	Accepted (N11766)

32.3Summary of discussions

M18708 France votes no with comment that known bugs need to be fixed. No such bugs are known at the moment. No action needed.

32.4Action Points

33MPEG-V Architecture (23005-1)

33.1Topics

33.1.1ISO/IEC 23005-1 MPEG-V Architecture

33.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-V	m19225	Descriptions of gas and dust sensors for MPEG-V part 1	Jae-Joon Han, Seungju Han, Won-Chul Bang, James D.K. Kim, Sang-Kyun Kim, Yong Soo Joo
MPEG-V	m19190	Proposal for Weather Change in Virtual World	Kyoungro Yoon, Soohan Kim, Woo Chool Park, Hae Moon Seo

33.3Summary of discussions

Refer 3DGC reports.

33.4Action Points

34Control Information (23005-2)

34.1Topics

34.1.1ISO/IEC 23005-2 Control Information

34.2Contributions

Session	Number	Title	Source		Dispositions
MPEG-V	m18928	Proposed changes for MPEG-V Control Information	Markus Waltl, Christian Timmerer