Both contributions taken as input to produce updated requirement document.
14.2.4Proposal for Standardization of Content Deliverables for Professionally Produced Film, TV, Video
M15216, M15105 : Working draft for proposed MPEG-M Production Deliverables standard & MPEG-M under the MPEG 21 Reflector.
The Systems sub-group, noting that :
it has generated a Post-production Deliverable (PPD) requirements document at the 82nd WG11 meeting that was not made publicly available
it has reviewed the results of the Ad hoc group on Requirements for MPEG Post Production Deliverable Formats (N9549)
it has developed a Post-production Deliverable (PPD) working draft (WD) at the 83rd WG 11 meeting
it has made a gap analysis between the current requirements and the PPD WD concluding that the WD provides a broad coverage of PPD requirements, but that
Some requirement are not yet formulated in a way that allows the development of a technical solution;
Some requirement were insufficiently documented to be able to perform the gap analysis;
Some requirements were not fully satisfied
recommends making the PPD Requirement document as well as the WD publicly available and to liaise with relevant SDOs and trade organizations that may have an interest in this activity inviting them to comment on the two documents and to join in the development of the PPD standard.
The Systems sub-group recommends promoting the proposed PPD specification to WD and progressing the PPD standard with the following time line:
CD : 2008/04
FCD : 2008/10
FDIS : 2009/04
The WD will be progressed to CD pending the successful completion of the gap analysis between the current requirements and the CD.