Executive Summary 1
Recommendations 11
Acknowledgements 26
Background 28
methodology 30
Article 4 — GENERAL OBLIGATIONS 33
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 33
No Legislation to Enact the CRPD 33
Disability Discrimination Legislation 33
National Disability Strategy 33
National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) 33
Engagement with People with Disability through their Representative Organisations 33
National and State Disability Advocacy Programs 34
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 4 34
Article 5 — Equality and non-DISCRIMINATION 36
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 36
Limitations of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) 37
A Failure to Address Intersectional Discrimination 37
Ineffective Complaints Process 38
Lack of Protection for Systemic Discrimination 39
Lack of Protection against Vilification and Hate Crimes (see also Articles 15 and 16) 40
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 5 40
Article 6 — wOMEN WITH dISABILITIES 41
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 41
Situation and Data about Girls and Women with Disability in Australia 41
Non-Therapeutic Sterilisation against Girls and Women with Disability (see Article 23) 41
Violence (see Article 16) 42
Discrimination and Inadequate Access to Healthcare (see Articles 23 and 25) 42
Discrimination in Employment and Remuneration (see Articles 27 and 28) 42
Overrepresentation and Treatment in the Prison System (see Articles 13 and 15) 42
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 6 43
Article 7 — Children with Disabilities 44
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 44
National Human Rights Protection 44
Freedom to Express Views Freely 45
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children and Young People with Disability 45
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 7 46
Article 8 — Awareness-raising 48
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 48
The Media 49
RECOMMENDATION Article 8 51
Article 9 — Accessibility 52
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 52
Disability Standards for Accessible Public Transport 2002 52
Barriers to Public transport 53
The Disability (Access to Premises — Building) Standards 2010 54
Accessibility and Australian Regulations and Policy 54
Digital Communication and Information (see also Article 21) 55
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 9 55
Article 10 — right to life 56
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 56
No Legislated Right to Life 56
Lower Life Expectancy 56
Deaths in Residential Disability and Aged Care Facilities 57
Denial of Life Saving Measures 58
Discriminatory Sentencing in Murder Cases 59
High Rates of Suicide 59
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 10 60
Article 11 — Situations of risk and humanitarian emergencies 61
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 61
Inaccessible Early Warning Systems (EWS) 62
Inaccessible Emergency Facilities 62
Lack of Inclusive Disaster Preparedness Planning and Consultation 62
Lack of Inclusive Planning in Reconstruction Efforts 62
Lack of Coordination 63
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 11 63
Article 12 — Equal recognition before the law 65
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 65
Australia’s Interpretative Declaration on Article 12 65
Discriminatory Laws, Policies and Practice 66
Guardianship, Estate Management and Mental Health Laws 67
Inadequacy of Administrative Arrangements 68
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 12 68
Article 13 — Access to justice 70
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 70
Legal Representation 71
Cost Barriers (See also Article 5) 72
Systemic Barriers 73
Reasonable Accommodation 74
Over-Representation in the Prison System 75
Over-Representation in the Juvenile Justice System 76
Trial by Jury 77
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 13 78
Article 14 — Liberty and security of the person 79
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 79
Guardianship Laws 79
Mental Health Laws and Tribunals 79
Arbitrary Detention in Prisons 81
Arbitrary Arrest and Detention (see also Article 13) 82
Rights in the Prison System 83
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 14 84
Article 15 — Freedom from torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment 85
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 85
Restrictive Practices 86
Disability Service System 88
Mental Health Service System 89
Restrictive Practices in Schools (see also Article 24) 90
In Prisons (see also Articles 13 and 14) 91
Juvenile Justice (see also Article 13) 93
Immigration Detention Centres 93
Medical or Scientific Experimentation Without Free and Informed Consent 94
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 15 95
Article 16 — Freedom from exploitation, violence and abuse 96
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 96
General Legal and Policy Framework 96
Incidence Data, Identification and Reporting 98
Institutions and Residential Care Facilities 100
Mental Health Services 102
In the Education System 103
Social Protection Measures and Support Programs 104
Domestic Violence Services 104
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 16 105
Article 17 — Protecting the integrity of the person 107
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 107
Australia’s Interpretative Declaration on Article 17 107
Involuntary Mental Health Treatment 109
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 17 112
Article 18 — LIBERTY OF MOVEMENT AND NATIONALITY 113
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 113
Australia’s Interpretative Declaration on Article 18 113
Failure to Consider the Potential Contribution of People with Disability 114
Mandatory HIV Testing 115
Lack of Freedom for People with Disability to Move within Australia 116
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 18 117
Article 19 — Living independently and being included in the community 118
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 118
General Legal and Policy Framework 118
Supported Accommodation, Residential Institutions and Other Specific Purpose Arrangements 119
Younger People Placed in Nursing Homes 121
Unavailable and Inadequate Housing and Supports (see also Articles 18, 20, 26 and 28) 121
Lack of Adequate, Accessible Social and Public Housing 124
Private Rental Housing and Home Ownership 126
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 19 127
Article 20 — Personal mobility 129
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 129
Program Funding and Access 129
Development of Assistive Devices, Aids and Equipment 131
People with Disability Living in Remote and Rural Areas 132
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 20 132
Article 21— Freedom of expression and opinion and access to information 133
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 133
Policy Framework 133
Government Information 133
Government Consultation Processes 135
No Official Recognition of Sign Languages 136
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 21 136
Article 22 — Respect for privacy 137
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 137
General Legislative Framework 137
Privacy Concerns arising from the Interaction of Government Agencies and e-health 137
A Lack of Respect for Privacy in Residential Care Facilities and Group Homes 138
Disclosure of “Disability” in Employment 138
Lack of Privacy Acts as Deterrent to the Making of Complaints 139
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 22 139
Article 23 — Respect for Home and the Family 140
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 140
Legal and Policy Framework 140
Non-Therapeutic Sterilisation 141
Removal of Children from Parents with Disability 142
Reproductive Freedom, Family Planning and Right to Parent 144
Coerced Abortions 144
Unequal Access to Adoption 145
Right to Sex and Relationships 145
Right of Children with Disability to Live in a Family 147
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 23 147
Article 24 — Education 149
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 149
General Legal and Policy Framework 149
Incidence of Educational Disadvantage 150
‘Special’ or Segregated Schools 150
Inclusive Mainstream Primary and Secondary Schools 151
Restrictive Practices, Bullying and Inappropriate Discipline 153
Inadequate Funding and Support Arrangements 154
Tertiary Education 155
Lack of Trained Teachers and Education Professionals 156
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 24 157
Article 25 — Health 159
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 159
Affordability of Health Care 159
Access Barriers 160
Population–Based Public Health Programs Fail to Include People with Disability 160
Women 161
Lack of Disability Specific Health Services 161
Lack of Services for People with a Psychosocial Disability 162
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians: Failure to Prevent Secondary Disabilities 162
Quality of Care, Communication and Training 163
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 25 163
article 26 — HABILITATION AND REHABILITATION 165
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 165
Access to Therapy or Allied Health Services 165
Underfunding of Disability Services 165
Health Services and Rehabilitation Programs 166
Rural Areas 167
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians 167
People from Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Backgrounds 167
People with Psychosocial Disability 168
Data Limitations 168
Aids and Equipment 168
Staff Training 169
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 26 169
Article 27 — Work and employment 170
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 170
Mainstream or Open Employment Support 173
Segregated Employment 174
Women with Disability 175
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 27 176
Article 28 — Adequate standard of living and social protection 178
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 178
Impairment Ratings Exclude Certain Disability Types 179
Waiting Period for Immigrants 180
Ensuring an Adequate Standard of Living 181
Lack of Measures Taken to Recognise the Connection between Poverty and Disability 182
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 28 183
aRTICLE 29 - PARTICIPATION IN POLITICAL AND PUBLIC LIFE 184
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 184
Exclusion from the Electoral Roll 184
Lack of Access to Secret Ballots 185
Inability to Access Postal Voting 187
Inaccessible Voting Locations and Information 187
Disenfranchisement of People with Disability 188
Absence of People with Disability in Representative Government Capacity 189
Insufficient Government Support to Representative Disability Organisations 189
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 29 190
Article 30 — Participation in cultural life, recreation, leisure and sport 192
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 192
Inaccessible Cultural Events, Performances and Materials 192
Lack of Opportunities to Develop Creative Endeavours 194
Inaccessible Tourism Services and Facilities 194
Low Participation Rates in Sport and Recreation 195
Friendship and Social Connections 196
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 30 196
Article 31 — statistics and data collection 197
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 197
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 31 198
Article 32 — International cooperation 199
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 199
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 32 200
Article 33 — National implementation and monitoring 201
STATUS IN AUSTRALIA 201
RECOMMENDATIONS Article 33 202
AbBreviations 204