Parallelism and planes in optimality theory: evidence from afar

Yüklə 2,55 Mb.
ölçüsü2,55 Mb.
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   19




Sandra Lee Fulmer

A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the


In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements

For the Degree of

Doctor of Philosophy
In the Graduate College


1 9 9


This dissertation has been submitted in partial fulfillment of requirements for an advanced degree at The University of Arizona and is deposited in the University Library to be made available to borrowers under rules of the library.
Brief quotations from this dissertation are allowable without special permission, provided that accurate acknowledgment of source is made. Requests for permission for extended quotation from or reproduction of this manuscript in whole or in part may be granted by the head of the major department or the Dean of the Graduate College when in his or her interests the proposed use of the material is in the interests of scholarship. In all other instances, however, permission must be obtained from the author.

I wish to thank the people who have been the most help to me in the ends and means of this dissertation. Of utmost importance has been Mike Hammond. Without his knowledge, encouragement, persistence friendship, and bridge playing, this document surely would have never been finished. Many of the ideas in here were inspired by him. I am also grateful for the help from my other committee members, Terry Langendoen and Dick Demers. They were always ready to discuss my ideas and share my enthusiasm for the variable-position phenomenon.
I also thank all the Linguistics graduate students I have spent time with during my tenure here. Every one of them has added something to my view of the Linguistic world. I would especially like to thank Diane Ohala, Amy Fountain, Pat Perez and Wendy Wiswall for their knowledge, ideas, proofreading skills and friendship. They have been much more than my colleagues.
I would also like to thank my husband, Bruce Walsh for his laughter, loving, nagging and housekeeping skills. He has been both a help and a delight during this process.
My undying gratitude goes out to Nan Crandall, Matt Shimel, Jennifer Wateuma, Fred Matter and Maria Teresa Velez for covering for me at work so that I take time off to finish my dissertation.
Finally, I would like to thank Trouble, Abby, Mouth, Rusty, Scamper, PeeWee, Duffy and Spot for keeping me sane during this process.

This dissertation is dedicated to my parents,

Gordon and Marjorie Fulmer,

who taught me with their love and understanding,

everything I will ever need to know.

Thank you.

1. Introduction 8

Background 16

Afar 17

Phonemics 18

Sounds 18

Co-occurrence Restrictions 25

Vowel Quality 26

Consonants 31

Morphology 38

General Morphology 39

Verb Classes 47

Theoretical Background 56

Introduction to Optimality Theory 57

Correspondence Theory 72

Generalized Alignment 76

Morphological Planes 78

The Morphemic Tier Hypothesis 79

Planes in Concatenative Languages 96

Morphological Planes and Optimality Theory 102

Huave 107

Dissertation Overview 112


Syllables 116

The Structure of Syllables 117

Closed-Syllable Long Vowel Reduction 134

Word Final Long Vowel Reduction 141

Superheavy Syllables 147

Long Vowels in Word-Final Position 164

The Minimal Word 164


Prosodic Vowels 169

The Deletion of /y/ 178

The Absence of [y] 186

Phonological Distribution 186

Morphological Alternations 189

Insertion or Deletion 192

Summary 199


The Data: The Person and Plural Markers 205

The Plural 224

An OT Account 232

Necessary Constraints 232

Inputs in Optimality Theory and Correspondence Theory 238

A Paradox for OT 240

Morphemic Tiers and OT 258

[a]-Initial Verbs 285

The Exceptions 301

Summary 310

4. Alternative Accounts in OT 313

A Linear Planes Analysis 315

Avoiding the Paradox with Levels 320

Problems with a Level-ordered Approach 358

Ad Hoc Levels 361

Consonant Co-occurrence Restrictions 362

Assimilation Constraints 369

5. Some Final Thoughts 403

Huave 405

Arabic 414

Optimal Domains and the Multiplanar Model 417

Possibilities for Axininca Campa 419

Conclusions 423

References 425

Appendix A 430

Abbreviations used 430


In this dissertation I show that the representations in Optimality Theory must be extended to allow multiple planes. The variable-position affixes in Afar occur as either prefixes or suffixes depending on the initial segment of the verb root. If the root begins with [i], [e(e)], [o(o)] or [u], the affix is a prefix (e.g., t-okm-e# (2-eat-perf) ‘You (sg.) ate’); if it begins with [a] or a consonant, the affix is a suffix (e.g., rab-t-e# (die-2-perf) ‘You died’). Additionally, plural not only appears as a prefix or a suffix, but when a suffix it can either precede or follow aspect (rab-n-e# (die-pl-perf) ‘I died’ vs. rab-e#-n (die-perf-pl) ‘They died’). A parallel model in Optimality Theory is unable to account for the different order of affixes in forms such as rab-n-e# vs. rab-e#-n. The Multiplanar Model, which posits that output representations consist not only of a word plane but also an affix plane is able to account for this data. The representations for the two forms are: [y-e-n], [rab-e-n] and [n-e], [rab-n-e]. In the first case, plural is specified as the rightmost morpheme by morphological constraints. Even though /y/, the third person marker, cannot surface on the word plane, it satisfies onset on the affix plane. This contrasts with the second case, where onset, being higher ranked than plural (r), requires that plural occurs to the left of aspect to fill the onset position on the affix plane. I then show a serial monoplanar model can also account for this data. Finally, I compare the serial and multiplanar models, arguing that phonological evidence supports the Multiplanar Model.

Kataloq: files
files -> Fövqəladə hallar və həyat fəaliyyətinin təhlükəsizliyi”
files -> Azərbaycan Respublikası Kənd Təsərrüfatı Nazirliyi Azərbaycan Dövlət Aqrar Universiteti adau-nun 80 illik yubileyinə həsr edilir adau-nun elmi ƏSƏRLƏRİ g əNCƏ 2009, №3
files -> Ümumi məlumat Fənnin adı, kodu və kreditlərin sayı
files -> Mühazirəotağı/Cədvəl I gün 16: 40-18: 00 #506 V gün 15: 10-16: 30 #412 Konsultasiyavaxtı
files -> Mühazirə otağı/Cədvəl ivgün saat 13 40 15 00 otaq 410 Vgün saat 13 40 15 00
files -> TƏDRİs plani iXTİsas: 050407 menecment
files -> AZƏrbaycan respublikasi təHSİl naziRLİYİ XƏZƏr universiteti TƏHSİl faküLTƏSİ
files -> Mühazirə otağı/Cədvəl Məhsəti küç., 11 (Neftçilər kampusu), 301 n saylı otaq Mühazirə: Çərşənbə axşamı, saat 16. 40-18. 00

Yüklə 2,55 Mb.

Dostları ilə paylaş:
  1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   ...   19

Verilənlər bazası müəlliflik hüququ ilə müdafiə olunur © 2022
rəhbərliyinə müraciət

    Ana səhifə