Summary of MARTE FTF Activities 1
Formation 1
Finalization Task Force Membership 2
Issue Disposition: 3
Voting Record: 4
Summary of Changes Made 11
Disposition: Resolved 12
OMG Issue No: 11337 12
OMG Issue No: 11337 12
Title: attribute “Naming conventions and typing errors” 12
Disposition: Resolved 13
OMG Issue No: 11338 13
OMG Issue No: 11338 13
Title: MARTE_Library::MeasurementUnits model library 13
Disposition: Resolved 16
OMG Issue No: 11339 16
OMG Issue No: 11339 16
Title: Section: Annex B3.3.3 16
Disposition: Resolved 17
OMG Issue No: 11340 17
OMG Issue No: 11340 17
Title: Section: Annex B3.3.3 p 397 (circular reference in time expression grammar) 17
Disposition: Resolved 18
OMG Issue No: 11402 18
OMG Issue No: 11402 18
Title: attribute “concept of resource(both classifier/instance)” 18
Disposition: Resolved 19
OMG Issue No: 11417 19
OMG Issue No: 11417 19
Title: Capitalize "rtf" Stereotype to "Rtf" 19
Disposition: UnderWay 20
OMG Issue No: 11504 20
OMG Issue No: 11504 20
Title: Annex D3 MARTE model library for time 20
Disposition: Resolved 26
OMG Issue No: 11520 26
OMG Issue No: 11520 26
Title: the property named "isSynchronous" is misspelled 26
Disposition: Resolved 29
OMG Issue No: 11521 29
OMG Issue No: 11521 29
Title: Figure 14.70 - HwCommunication package details 29
Disposition: Resolved 37
OMG Issue No: 11522 37
OMG Issue No: 11522 37
Title: The type NFP_Price does not exist in the document. 37
Disposition: Resolved 40
OMG Issue No: 11526 40
OMG Issue No: 11526 40
Title: Section 2/2.2 40
Disposition: Resolved 41
OMG Issue No: 11527 41
OMG Issue No: 11527 41
Title: Issue 11527: Section 6/6/2/1 41
Disposition: Resolved 42
OMG Issue No: 11528 42
OMG Issue No: 11528 42
Title: Issue 11528: Section 6/6.3 42
Disposition: Resolved 44
OMG Issue No: 11529 44
OMG Issue No: 11529 44
Title: Issue 11529: Section 6/6.4 44
Disposition: Resolved 46
OMG Issue No: 11530 46
OMG Issue No: 11530 46
Title: Issue 11530: first sentence of sub-section 6.4.2 46
Disposition: Resolved 47
OMG Issue No: 11545 47
OMG Issue No: 11545 47
Title: grammar defined for conditional expressions (condition part should support logical comparison) 47
Disposition: Resolved 48
OMG Issue No: 11546 48
OMG Issue No: 11546 48
Title: Wrong references in page 397 48
Disposition: Resolved 49
OMG Issue No: 11547 49
OMG Issue No: 11547 49
Title: VSL meta-model 49
Disposition: Resolved 51
OMG Issue No: 11550 51
OMG Issue No: 11550 51
Title: non-terminal symbol automotive example (Completeness of Namespace in VSL grammar Remove “automotive example” from the original title) 51
Disposition: Resolved 52
OMG Issue No: 11551 52
OMG Issue No: 11551 52
Title: automotive example (marte-ftf) 52
Disposition: Resolved 57
OMG Issue No: 11552 57
OMG Issue No: 11552 57
Title: attribute “GRM SchedulableResource should not have a property "host ExecutionHost"” 57
Disposition: Resolved 58
OMG Issue No: 11553 58
OMG Issue No: 11553 58
Title: Issue 11530: first sentence of sub-section 6.4.2 58
Disposition: Resolved 59
OMG Issue No: 11554 59
OMG Issue No: 11554 59
Title: Class descriptions are missing (in Annex D) 59
Disposition: Resolved 64
OMG Issue No: 11555 64
OMG Issue No: 11555 64
Title: attribute “Class descriptions are missing in the MARTE model library for GRM (Annex D4)” 64
Disposition: Resolved 65
OMG Issue No: 11620 65
OMG Issue No: 11620 65
Title: EventTrace attributes 65
Disposition: Resolved 66
OMG Issue No: 11631 66
OMG Issue No: 11631 66
Title: {title of the issue} 66
Disposition: Resolved 67
OMG Issue No: 11632 67
OMG Issue No: 11632 67
Title: Section: 14.2.3 67
Disposition: Resolved 68
OMG Issue No: 11644 68
OMG Issue No: 11644 68
Title: Section: Annex B.2.4 (direction property is not consistent between MM and grammar) 68
Disposition: Resolved 69
OMG Issue No: 11649 69
OMG Issue No: 11649 69
Title: Minor edits to MARTE 69
Disposition: Resolved 83
OMG Issue No: 11660 83
OMG Issue No: 11660 83
Title: N/A 83
Disposition: Resolved 85
OMG Issue No: 11661 85
OMG Issue No: 11661 85
Title: Section: 11.2.1 85
Disposition: Resolved 90
OMG Issue No: 11664 90
OMG Issue No: 11664 90
Title: Section 11.3.1 90
Disposition: Resolved 92
OMG Issue No: 11665 92
OMG Issue No: 11665 92
Title: Section: 11.3.1 figure 11.6 92
Disposition: Resolved 94
OMG Issue No: 11692 94
OMG Issue No: 11692 94
Title: Section: 14.2 94
Disposition: Resolved 96
OMG Issue No: 11693 96
OMG Issue No: 11693 96
Title: the property named "isSynchronous" is misspelled 96
Disposition: Resolved 99
OMG Issue No: 11694 99
OMG Issue No: 11694 99
Title: HwTiming model of the HwLogical profile 99
Disposition: Resolved 100
OMG Issue No: 11696 100
OMG Issue No: 11696 100
Title: Suggest to extend ClockConstraints to ClockTypes 100
Disposition: Resolved 102
OMG Issue No: 11704 102
OMG Issue No: 11704 102
Title: Editorial issue 102
Disposition: Resolved 103
OMG Issue No: 11705 103
OMG Issue No: 11705 103
Title: In 12.4, all references to figures are wrong 103
Disposition: Resolved 106
OMG Issue No: 11765 106
OMG Issue No: 11765 106
Title: [NFP: Profile]. Fig 8.4 (statisticalQualifier and Direction as stereotype attributes of <>) 106
Disposition: Resolved 109
OMG Issue No: 11766 109
OMG Issue No: 11766 109
Title: [Time] Fig. 9.29 109
Disposition: Resolved 111
OMG Issue No: 11769 111
OMG Issue No: 11769 111
Title: attribute “GRM Example Fig10.21” 111
Disposition: Resolved 112
OMG Issue No: 11772 112
OMG Issue No: 11772 112
Title: HRM: Examples 112
Disposition: Resolved 115
OMG Issue No: 11773 115
OMG Issue No: 11773 115
Title: GQAM General 115
OMG Issue No: 11774 117
OMG Issue No: 11774 117
Title: : GQAM: Domain Model & Profile (01), <
> 117
Disposition: Resolved 120
OMG Issue No: 11777 120
OMG Issue No: 11777 120
Title: {title of the issue} 120
Disposition: Resolved 121
OMG Issue No: 11778 121
OMG Issue No: 11778 121
Title: What is the Meaning of "Business Management Perspective"? 121
Disposition: Resolved 122
OMG Issue No: 11779 122
OMG Issue No: 11779 122
Title: attribute “GRM, GQAM, SAM: DomainModel & Profile SAM” 122
Disposition: Resolved 124
OMG Issue No: 11781 124
OMG Issue No: 11781 124
Title: NFP: value syntax (adopt a compact graphic notation for NfpType values: value + unit) 124
Disposition: Resolved 126
OMG Issue No: 11818 126
OMG Issue No: 11818 126
Title: Section: 1 MARTE spelling missing in the introduction 126
Disposition: Resolved 127
OMG Issue No: 11829 127
OMG Issue No: 11829 127
Title: Figure E.6 (p 460) 127
Disposition: Resolved 128
OMG Issue No: 11830 128
OMG Issue No: 11830 128
Title: Reshape stereotype (pp 463,464) 128
Disposition: Resolved 129
OMG Issue No: 11831 129
OMG Issue No: 11831 129
Title: Shaped stereotype (pp 464,465) 129
Disposition: Resolved 130
OMG Issue No: 11832 130
OMG Issue No: 11832 130
Title: Tiler stereotype (pp 465,466) 130
Disposition: Resolved 132
OMG Issue No: 11833 132
OMG Issue No: 11833 132
Title: E.4 Examples (pp 467,468) 132
Disposition: Resolved 134
OMG Issue No: 11834 134
OMG Issue No: 11834 134
Title: Figure E.10 (p 468) 134
Disposition: Resolved 135
OMG Issue No: 11835 135
OMG Issue No: 11835 135
Title: RTEConnector should be removed from RTEMoCC 135
Disposition: Resolved 137
OMG Issue No: 11836 137
OMG Issue No: 11836 137
Title: Rename Subprofile RTEMoCC 137
Disposition: Resolved 138
OMG Issue No: 11837 138
OMG Issue No: 11837 138
Title: chapter 11 (GCM) should be moved in the Part II of the specification 138
Disposition: Resolved 140
OMG Issue No: 11843 140
OMG Issue No: 11843 140
Title: How to model the size the heap size of an Ada runtime with SRM? 140
Disposition: Resolved 143
OMG Issue No: 11846 143
OMG Issue No: 11846 143
Title: Enhance the concept of Observer in GQAM 143
Disposition: Resolved 146
OMG Issue No: 11847 146
OMG Issue No: 11847 146
Title: description of the Clock stereotype 146
Disposition: Resolved 147
OMG Issue No: 11848 147
OMG Issue No: 11848 147
Title: a full UML profile for AADL 147
Source: 147
Disposition: Resolved 152
OMG Issue No: 11852 152
OMG Issue No: 11852 152
Title: AADL pre-declared property set representation with MARTE 152
Disposition: Resolved 160
OMG Issue No: 11857 160
OMG Issue No: 11857 160
Title: What is the Meaning of "Business Management Perspective"? 160
Disposition: Resolved 161
OMG Issue No: 11858 161
OMG Issue No: 11858 161
Title: Section: 1 MARTE spelling missing in the introduction 161
Disposition: Resolved 163
OMG Issue No: 11859 163
OMG Issue No: 11859 163
Title: Section: 1 MARTE spelling missing in the introduction 163
Disposition: Resolved 166
OMG Issue No: 11860 166
OMG Issue No: 11860 166
Title: In section 2.4.2, the list of extension units and table 7.2 are redundant 166
Disposition: Resolved 168
OMG Issue No: 11861 168
OMG Issue No: 11861 168
Title: attribute “rephrase section 7.3” 168
Disposition: Resolved 170
OMG Issue No: 11862 170
OMG Issue No: 11862 170
Title: attribute “Add short rationale in section 10.3” 170
Disposition: Resolved 171
OMG Issue No: 11863 171
OMG Issue No: 11863 171
Title: concept of refinement 171
Disposition: Resolved 174
OMG Issue No: 11865 174
OMG Issue No: 11865 174
Title: RtAction.isAtomic 174
Disposition: Resolved 175
OMG Issue No: 11867 175
OMG Issue No: 11867 175
Title: For the sake of consistency, the rtf stereotype should be renamed 175
Disposition: Resolved 177
OMG Issue No: 11868 177
OMG Issue No: 11868 177
Title: suggest removing the notion of feature in the conformance section 177
Disposition: Resolved 178
OMG Issue No: 11869 178
OMG Issue No: 11869 178
Title: Section 6: Remove the MSWord comment 178
Disposition: Resolved 179
OMG Issue No: 11870 179
OMG Issue No: 11870 179
Title: In section 6.1, I would suggest mentioning RTCORBA and CCM 179
Disposition: Resolved 180
OMG Issue No: 11875 180
OMG Issue No: 11875 180
Title: Relationship between Alloc::Allocation and SRM::EntryPoint 180
Disposition: Resolved 184
OMG Issue No: 11877 184
OMG Issue No: 11877 184
Title: In Annex D, I would suggest make unit names 184
Disposition: Resolved 186
OMG Issue No: 11885 186
OMG Issue No: 11885 186
Title: page 271, Fig.15.7 and in Annex D, page 437, Fig.D.5 (Arrival pattern data type) 186
Disposition: Resolved 193
OMG Issue No: 11887 193
OMG Issue No: 11887 193
Title: attribute “resMult” 193
Disposition: Resolved 197
OMG Issue No: 11888 197
OMG Issue No: 11888 197
Title: Missing attribute in figure 17.17 197
Disposition: Resolved 199
OMG Issue No: 11890 199
OMG Issue No: 11890 199
Title: Unfinished Sentence 199
Disposition: Resolved 200
OMG Issue No: 11891 200
OMG Issue No: 11891 200
Title: {title of the issue} 200
Disposition: Resolved 201
OMG Issue No: 11892 201
OMG Issue No: 11892 201
Title: {title of the issue} 201
Disposition: Resolved 202
OMG Issue No: 11707 202
OMG Issue No: 11707 202
Title: Consider providing a tabular notation for Allocation constraints 202
Disposition: Resolved 203
OMG Issue No: 11770 203
OMG Issue No: 11770 203
Title: [Alloc: Profile 203
Disposition: Resolved 207
OMG Issue No: 11771 207
OMG Issue No: 11771 207
Title: Declarations of Time Observations are Incorrect in Figure 13.22 207
Disposition: Resolved 208
OMG Issue No: 11778 208
OMG Issue No: 11778 208
Title: “[SAM: Profile] (association of SaStep to SharedResource in UML View)” 208
Disposition: Resolved 210
OMG Issue No: 11780 210
OMG Issue No: 11780 210
Title: Details for Time-triggered Systems' TimeTableDriven Policy 210
Disposition: Resolved 212
OMG Issue No: 11880 212
OMG Issue No: 11880 212
Title: HRM::HwMemory 212
Disposition: Resolved 215
OMG Issue No: 11882 215
OMG Issue No: 11882 215
Title: “Missing Delay and Offset in SAM” 215
Disposition: Resolved 217
OMG Issue No: 11886 217
OMG Issue No: 11886 217
Title: use of stereotype names in UML model examples is inconsistent 217
Disposition: Resolved 219
OMG Issue No: 11889 219
OMG Issue No: 11889 219
Title: Typos 219
Disposition: Resolved 220
OMG Issue No: {12194} 220
OMG Issue No: {12194} 220
Source:,) Nature: Revision Severity: Minor Summary: 220
Resolution: 220
Title: ExecHost.thoughput 220
In GQAM, the profile diagram (Figure 15.6) defines a stereotype attribute GaExecHost.throughput that is not documented in section 15.3.2 or introduced in the domain model (Figure 15.5) 220
Disposition: Resolved 222
OMG Issue No: 12214 222
OMG Issue No: 12214 222
Title: Wrong direction of the allocation 222
Disposition: Resolved 223
OMG Issue No: 12232 223
OMG Issue No: 12232 223
Title: Rename every instance of "SaEnd2EndFlow" to "SaEndToEndFlow" 223
Disposition: Resolved 226
OMG Issue No: 12240 226
OMG Issue No: 12240 226
Title: picture 11.8, ports "loc" and "ftp" (marte-ftf) 226
Disposition: Resolved 227
OMG Issue No: 12242 227
OMG Issue No: 12242 227
Title: VSL variable declaration (inconsistency between the BNF and the metamodel) 227
Disposition: Resolved 228
OMG Issue No: 12246 228
OMG Issue No: 12246 228
Title: Section 16.2.2 (SAM) 228
Disposition: Resolved 229
OMG Issue No: 12247 229
OMG Issue No: 12247 229
Title: page 288: change explanation 229
Disposition: Resolved 230
OMG Issue No: 12248 230
OMG Issue No: 12248 230
Title: Section: Annex B (VSL) 230
Disposition: Resolved 231
OMG Issue No: 12283 231
OMG Issue No: 12283 231
Title: TimingObserver in GQAM should be renamed to TimedObserver 231
Source: 231
Disposition: Resolved 234
OMG Issue No: 12371 234
OMG Issue No: 12371 234
Title: {Delay times in GQAM and PAM} 234
Disposition: Resolved 237
OMG Issue No: 12402 237
OMG Issue No: 12402 237
Title: Specify a maximum number of period for periodic real-time constraints 237
Disposition: Resolved 240
OMG Issue No: 12410 240
OMG Issue No: 12410 240
Title: Type NFP_Weight does not exist 240
Disposition: Resolved 243
OMG Issue No: 12414 243
OMG Issue No: 12414 243
Title: {title of the issue} 243
Disposition: Resolved 246
OMG Issue No: 12418 246
OMG Issue No: 12418 246
Title: “GQAM Domain view inheritances from GRM” 246
Disposition: Resolved 254
OMG Issue No: 12428 254
OMG Issue No: 12428 254
Title: wrong multiplicity in sharedResources required for a SaStep 254
Disposition: Deferred 257
OMG Issue No: 11411 257
OMG Issue No: 11411 257
Title: attribute “SwSchedulableResource does not inherit from GRM::SchedulableResource stereotype” 257
Disposition: Deferred 258
OMG Issue No: 11412 258
OMG Issue No: 11412 258
Title: attribute “SwMutualExclusionResource does not inherit from GRM::MutualExclusionResource stereotype” 258
Disposition: Deferred 259
OMG Issue No: 11544 259
OMG Issue No: 11544 259
Title: Annex D 259
Disposition: Deferred 260
OMG Issue No: 11549 260
OMG Issue No: 11549 260
Title: Annex B VSL BNF 260
Disposition: Resolved 261
OMG Issue No: 11633 261
OMG Issue No: 11633 261
Title: Annex B VSL BNF 261
Disposition: Deferred 262
OMG Issue No: 11767 262
OMG Issue No: 11767 262
Title: Time: Examples 262
Disposition: Deferred 263
OMG Issue No: 11768 263
OMG Issue No: 11768 263
Title: GRM: Domain Model 263
Disposition: Deferred 265
OMG Issue No: 11764 265
OMG Issue No: 11764 265
Title: Section: NFP 265
Disposition: Deferred 266
OMG Issue No: 11817 266
OMG Issue No: 11817 266
Title: Section: HRM 266
Disposition: Deferred 267
OMG Issue No: 11820 267
OMG Issue No: 11820 267
Title: ports in GCM 267
Disposition: Deferred 268
OMG Issue No: 11838 268
OMG Issue No: 11838 268
Title: Explain the Meaning of NFP Constraints which are Applied to Provided and Required Interfaces 268
Disposition: Deferred 269
OMG Issue No: 11839 269
OMG Issue No: 11839 269
Title: the GCM [now RTEMoCC] chapter should define a causality model for flows 269
Disposition: Deferred 270
OMG Issue No: 11840 270
OMG Issue No: 11840 270
Title: Support for flows in activities 270
Disposition: Deferred 272
OMG Issue No. 11845 272
OMG Issue No. 11845 272
Title: Runtimes may have multiple stacks 272
Disposition: Deferred 273
OMG Issue No: 11849 273
OMG Issue No: 11849 273
Title: Mode and End to End flow representation representation 273
Disposition: Deferred 274
OMG Issue No: 11850 274
OMG Issue No: 11850 274
Title: Annex A: guidance nature of the Annex 274
Disposition: Deferred 275
OMG Issue No: 11851 275
OMG Issue No: 11851 275
Title: How to use MARTE to modelize AADL applications 275
Disposition: Deferred 276
OMG Issue No: 11853 276
OMG Issue No: 11853 276
Title: MARTE VSL and AADL expression language alignment 276
Disposition: Deferred 277
OMG Issue No: 11854 277
OMG Issue No: 11854 277
Title: AADL examplification 277
Disposition: Deferred 278
OMG Issue No: 11855 278
OMG Issue No: 11855 278
Title: Dequeued Protocol AllItems representation 278
Disposition: Deferred 279
OMG Issue No: 11856 279
OMG Issue No: 11856 279
Title: attribute “Synchronisation between SRM, GRM, HRM and analysis part” 279
Disposition: Deferred 282
OMG Issue No: 11871 282
OMG Issue No: 11871 282
Title: NFP does not introduce the concept of dimension 282
Disposition: Deferred 283
OMG Issue No: 11872 283
OMG Issue No: 11872 283
Title: VSL 283
Disposition: Deferred 284
OMG Issue No: 11876 284
OMG Issue No: 11876 284
Title: MARTE primitive types 284
Disposition: Deferred 285
OMG Issue No: 11878 285
OMG Issue No: 11878 285
Title: Annex B: how VSL constructs shall be typed and evaluated 285
Disposition: Deferred 288
OMG Issue No: 11881 288
OMG Issue No: 11881 288
Title: Section: HRM 288
Disposition: Deferred 289
OMG Issue No: 11883 289
OMG Issue No: 11883 289
Title: Support for Views or sets of profile annotations 289
Disposition: Deferred 290
OMG Issue No: 11884 290
OMG Issue No: 11884 290
Title: Consistency between RTEMoCC, SAM, and SRM 290
Disposition: Deferred 291
OMG Issue No: 12196 291
OMG Issue No: 12196 291
Title: Section: 8.3.3.1 (New distribution functions) 291
Disposition: Closed, no change 293
OMG Issue No: 11163 293
OMG Issue No: 11163 293
Title: Consider adding a new attribute to «boundedSubtype» 293
Disposition: Closed No Change 294
OMG Issue No: 11548 294
OMG Issue No: 11548 294
Title: Annex B VSL BNF 294
Disposition: Closed, no change 295
OMG Issue No: 11619 295
OMG Issue No: 11619 295
Title: Section: 14/2 295
Disposition: Closed, no change 296
OMG Issue No: 11658 296
OMG Issue No: 11658 296
Title: Section: 11.2.1 296
Disposition: Closed, no change 297
OMG Issue No: 11659 297
OMG Issue No: 11659 297
Title: Section: 11.2.1 297
Disposition: Closed, no change 298
OMG Issue No: 11776 298
OMG Issue No: 11776 298
Title: Move Observer package to Part I or II 298
Disposition: Closed, no change 299
OMG Issue No: 11822 299
OMG Issue No: 11822 299
Title: Giving an attribute a variable name and an expression value 299
Disposition: Closed, no change 300
OMG Issue No: 11841 300
OMG Issue No: 11841 300
Title: How to model the amount of memory occupied by an OS resource 300
Disposition: Closed, no change 301
OMG Issue No: 11844 301
OMG Issue No: 11844 301
Title: How to model the size of code occupied in ROM? 301
Disposition: Closed, no change 302
OMG Issue No: 11864 302
OMG Issue No: 11864 302
Title: Names should be identical 302
Disposition: Closed, no change 303
OMG Issue No: 11866 303
OMG Issue No: 11866 303
Title: Improve the usability of the RtBehavior stereotype 303
Disposition: Closed, no change 304
OMG Issue No: 11873 304
OMG Issue No: 11873 304
Title: allocatedTo and allocatedFrom properties should not be derived 304
Disposition: Closed, no change 306
OMG Issue No: 11874 306
OMG Issue No: 11874 306
Title: attribute “GRM::SchedulableResource should have a period property” 306
Disposition: Closed, no change 307
OMG Issue No: 12185 307
OMG Issue No: 12185 307
Title: RTF stereotype 307
Disposition: Closed, no change 308
OMG Issue No: 12209 308
OMG Issue No: 12209 308
Title: using $ in naming variables (and variable calls) 308
Disposition: Duplicate/merged 311
OMG Issue No: 11662 311
OMG Issue No: 11662 311
Title: Section: 11.2.1 (data reception) 311
Disposition: Duplicate/merged 312
OMG Issue No: 11663 312
OMG Issue No: 11663 312
Title: Section 11.3.2 312
Disposition: Duplicate/merged 313
OMG Issue No: 11666 313
OMG Issue No: 11666 313
Title: Section 11.4.1 (marte-ftf) 313
Disposition: Duplicate/merged 314
OMG Issue No: 11667 314
OMG Issue No: 11667 314
Title: Section 11.4.1 (marte-ftf) 314
Disposition: Duplicate 315
OMG Issue No: 11775 315
OMG Issue No: 11775 315
Title: Move Observer package to Part I or II 315
Disposition: Duplicated 316
OMG Issue No: 11842 316
OMG Issue No: 11842 316
Title: attribute “HwMedia.bandwidth attribute may need to be generalized in GRM ancestor class” 316
Disposition: Duplicate 317
OMG Issue No: 11879 317
OMG Issue No: 11879 317
Title: HRM::HwMemory stereotype 317
Disposition: Duplicate/merged 318
OMG Issue No: 11885 318
OMG Issue No: 11885 318
Title: page 271, Fig.15.7 and in Annex D, page 437, Fig.D.5 (Arrival pattern data type) 318