International organisation for standardisation organisation internationale de normalisation

INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION FOR STANDARDISATION

ORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE NORMALISATION

ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11

CODING OF MOVING PICTURES AND AUDIO
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11 N11243

Dresden, DE – April 2009

Source:	Leonardo Chiariglione
Title:	Report of 92^nd meeting
Status

1 Opening 8

2 Roll call of participants 8

3 Approval of agenda 8

4 Allocation of contributions 8

5 Communications from Convenor 8

6 Report of previous meeting 8

7 Processing of NB Position Papers 8

8 Work plan management 9

8.1 Media coding 9

8.2 Composition coding 10

8.3 Description coding 10

8.4 Systems support 10

8.5 Transport and File formats 11

8.6 Multimedia architecture 11

8.7 Reference implementation 12

8.8 Conformance 13

8.9 Maintenance 14

8.10 Work plan and time line 14

9 Organisation of this meeting 15

9.1 Tasks for subgroups 15

9.2 Joint meetings 16

10 WG management 16

10.1 Terms of reference 16

10.2 Editors 17

10.3 Liaisons 17

10.4 Responses to National Bodies 17

10.5 Ad hoc groups 17

10.6 Asset management 18

10.7 IPR management 18

11 Administrative matters 19

11.1 Schedule of future MPEG meetings 19

11.2 Promotional activities 19

12 Resolutions of this meeting 19

13 A.O.B. 19

14 Closing 19

Annex A – Attendance list 21

Annex B – Agenda 27

Annex C – Input contributions 31

Annex D – Output documents 46

Annex E - Requirements report 50

1. Requirements documents approved at this meeting 50

2. Video 50

3. Explorations 50

3.1. Compact Descriptors for Visual Search 50

3.2. MPEG Font Formats 51

3.3. High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) 51

3.4. Advanced IPTV Terminal (AIT) 51

3.5. Transport of MPEG Media 51

3.6. Royalty-free Codecs 54

Annex F - Systems report 57

1. Output of the Meeting 57

1.1 Goals for the week 57

2. General Input Documents 58

2.1 AHG reports 58

2.2 General technical contributions 58

2.3 Demo 58

2.4 FAQ 59

2.5 AOB 59

3. MPEG-2 Systems (13818-1) 59

3.1 Topics 59

3.2 Contributions 59

3.3 Summary of discussions 60

3.4 Action Points 60

4. MPEG-4 System (14496-1) 60

4.1 Topics 60

4.2 Contributions 60

4.3 Summary of discussions 60

4.4 Action Points 61

5. MPEG-4 Conformance (14496-4) 61

5.1 Topics 61

5.2 Contributions 61

5.3 Summary of discussions 61

5.4 Action Points 61

6. MPEG-4 Reference Software (14496-5) 61

6.1 Topics 61

6.2 Contributions 61

6.3 Summary of discussions 61

6.4 Action Points 61

7. MPEG-4 BIFS (14496-11) 62

7.1 Topics 62

7.2 Contributions 62

7.3 Summary of discussions 62

7.4 Action Points 62

8. MPEG-4 ISO Base File Format (14496-12) 62

8.1 Topics 62

8.2 Contributions 63

8.3 Summary of discussions 63

8.4 Action Points 63

9. MPEG-4 File Format (14496-14) 63

9.1 Topics 63

9.2 Contributions 63

9.3 Summary of discussions 63

9.4 Action Points 63

10. MPEG-4 AVC File Format (14496-15) 63

10.1 Topics 64

10.2 Contributions 64

10.3 Summary of discussions 64

10.4 Action Points 64

11. LASeR & SAF (14496-20) 64

11.1 Topics 64

11.2 Contributions 64

11.3 Summary of discussions 65

11.4 Action Points 65

12. Open Font Format (14496-22) 65

12.1 Topics 65

12.2 Contributions 65

12.3 Summary of discussions 65

12.4 Action Points 65

13. MPEG Query Format (15938-12) 66

13.1 Topics 66

13.2 Contributions 66

13.3 Summary of discussions 66

13.4 Action Points 66

14. MPEG-21 DID (21000-2) 66

14.1 Topics 66

14.2 Contributions 66

14.3 Summary of discussions 67

14.4 Action Points 67

15. MPEG-21 IPMP Components (21000-4) 67

15.1 Topics 67

15.2 Contributions 67

15.3 Summary of discussions 67

15.4 Action Points 67

16. Media Value Chain Ontology (21000-19) 67

16.1 Topics 67

16.2 Contributions 67

16.3 Summary of discussions 68

16.4 Action Points 68

17. Media Streaming AF (23000-5) 68

17.1 Topics 68

17.2 Contributions 68

17.3 Summary of discussions 68

17.4 Action Points 69

18. Professional Archival AF (23000-6) 69

18.1 Topics 69

18.2 Contributions 69

18.3 Summary of discussions 69

18.4 Action Points 69

19. DMB AF (23000-9) 69

19.1 Topics 69

19.2 Contributions 69

19.3 Summary of discussions 70

19.4 Action Points 70

20. Video Surveillance AF (23000-10) 70

20.1 Topics 70

20.2 Contributions 70

20.3 Summary of discussions 70

20.4 Action Points 70

21. Stereoscopic Video AF (23000-11) 70

21.1 Topics 70

21.2 Contributions 70

21.3 Summary of discussions 71

21.4 Action Points 71

22. Interactive Music AF (23000-12) 71

22.1 Topics 71

22.2 Contributions 71

22.3 Summary of discussions 71

22.4 Action Points 71

23. MXM Architecture (23006-1) 72

23.1 Topics 72

23.2 Contributions 72

23.3 Summary of discussions 72

23.4 Action Points 72

24. MXM APIs (23006-2) 72

24.1 Topics 72

24.2 Contributions 72

24.3 Summary of discussions 73

24.4 Action Points 73

25. MXM Conf. & Ref. SW (23006-3) 73

25.1 Topics 73

25.2 Contributions 73

25.3 Summary of discussions 73

25.4 Action Points 73

26. MXM Protocol (23006-4) 73

26.1 Topics 73

26.2 Contributions 73

26.3 Summary of discussions 74

26.4 Action Points 74

27. MPEG-U Widgets (23007-1) 74

27.1 Topics 74

27.2 Contributions 74

27.3 Summary of discussions 74

27.4 Action Points 74

28. Advanced User Interaction Interface (23007-2) 75

28.1 Topics 75

28.2 Contributions 75

28.3 Summary of discussions 75

28.4 Action Points 75

29. MPEG-U Conformance and Reference Software (23007-3) 75

29.1 Topics 75

29.2 Contributions 75

29.3 Summary of discussions 76

29.4 Action Points 76

30. MPEG-V Architecture (23005-1) 76

30.1 Topics 76

30.2 Contributions 76

30.3 Summary of discussions 77

30.4 Action Points 77

31. Control Information (23005-2) 77

31.1 Topics 77

31.2 Contributions 77

31.3 Summary of discussions 77

31.4 Action Points 77

32. Sensory Information (23005-3) 78

32.1 Topics 78

32.2 Contributions 78

32.3 Summary of discussions 78

32.4 Action Points 79

33. Virtual World Object Characteristics (23005-4) 79

33.1 Topics 79

33.2 Contributions 79

33.3 Summary of discussions 79

33.4 Action Points 79

34. Data formats for interaction devices (23005-5) 80

34.1 Topics 80

34.2 Contributions 80

34.3 Summary of discussions 80

34.4 Action Points 80

35. Common types and tools (23005-6) 80

35.1 Topics 80

35.2 Contributions 80

35.3 Summary of discussions 81

35.4 Action Points 81

36. Conformance and reference software (23005-7) 81

36.1 Topics 81

36.2 Contributions 81

36.3 Summary of discussions 81

36.4 Action Points 81

37. Exploration – Advanced IPTV Terminal 82

37.1 Topics 82

37.2 Contributions 82

37.3 Summary of discussions 84

37.4 Action Points 85

38. Exploration – MMT 85

38.1 Topics 85

38.2 Contributions 85

38.3 Summary of discussions 85

38.4 Action Points 86

39. Liaison 86

39.1 List of input liaison letters 86

39.2 List of output liaison letters 86

40. Resolutions of Systems 86

41. Action Plan 87

41.1 Contribution to MPEG Homepage 87

42. References 88

42.1 Program of work 88

42.2 Timeline of standards under development (to be revised) 88

42.3 Standing Documents 89

42.4 Mailing Lists Reminder 91

Annex G - Video report 93

1 MPEG-4 part 2 maintenance 93

2 Development of AVC 93

3 MPEG-7 Visual 94

3.1 MPEG-7 Visual related work 94

3.2 Output documents related to MPEG-7 Visual 95

4 Reconfigurable Video Coding (RVC) 95

5 Explorations – 3D Video 96

Annex H - JCT report 101

Summary 101

1 Administrative topics 102

1.1 Organization 102

1.2 Meeting logistics 102

1.3 Primary goals 102

1.4 Documents 102

1.5 Attendance 103

1.6 Agenda 103

1.7 IPR policy reminder 103

1.8 Communication practices 104

1.9 Some terminology 104

1.10 Liaison activity 104

2 Joint Call for Proposals (CfP) review and responses 104

2.1 CfP overview 104

2.2 Considerations regarding review of CfP results 105

2.3 CfP response submission cross-checking activity 106

2.4 Architectural structure of proposal designs 107

2.5 Subjective test results 107

2.6 Tools for CfP response evaluation 107

2.7 Formal proposal responses to CfP 107

3 Additional contributions 129

3.1 Guidance on working methods 129

3.2 Video coding technology proposals 130

3.3 Video source material for experimentation 133

3.4 Test model basis suggestion submitted during meeting 133

4 Actions taken and future work planning 135

4.1 Informal naming 135

4.2 Planning the video coding specification deliverable 135

4.3 Tentative conclusions from CfP proposal reviews 135

4.4 Generation of a Test Model under Consideration (TMuC) 136

4.5 Software development planning 137

4.6 Planning of Tool Experiments (TEs) and Core Experiments (CEs) 138

4.7 Ad hoc groups formed 140

4.8 Meeting resolutions conveyed to the WG 11 parent body 142

4.9 Standardization timeline 143

4.10 Future meeting plans 143

4.11 Closing remarks 144

JCT-VC Report Annex A – Document list 145

JCT-VC Report Annex B – Attendance 154

Annex I - Audio report 160

1 Opening Audio Plenary 167

2 Administrative matters 167

2.1 Communications from the Chair 167

2.2 Approval of agenda and allocation of contributions 167

2.3 Creation of Task Groups 167

2.4 Approval of previous meeting report 167

2.5 Review of AHG reports 167

2.6 Joint meetings 167

2.7 Received National Body Comments and Liaison matters 167

2.8 Plenary Discussion 167

3 Record of AhG meetings 168

3.1 AhG Meeting on USAC -- Sunday 1000-1800 168

4 Task group activities 168

4.1 Task Group discussions 168

5 Closing Audio Plenary and meeting deliverables 184

5.1 Plenary discussions 184

5.2 Responses to Liaison and NB comments 184

5.3 Recommendations for final plenary 184

5.4 Establishment of Ad-hoc Groups 185

5.5 Approval of output documents 185

5.6 Press statement 185

5.7 Agenda for next meeting 185

5.8 All other business 185

5.9 Closing of the meeting 185

Annex A Participants 186

Annex B Audio Contributions and Schedule 187

Task Groups 191

Annex C Output Documents 192

Annex D Agenda for the 93nd MPEG Audio Meeting 193

Annex J - 3DG report 195

1 Opening of the meeting 195

1.1 Approval of the agenda 195

1.2 Goals for the week 195

1.3 Standards from 3DGC 195

1.4 Room allocation 196

1.5 Allocation of contributions 197

2 General issues 199

2.1 General discussion 199

3 Current Voting 199

4 General 3DG related activities 199

4.1 AhG on 3DG activities 199

4.2 Promotions 200

4.3 Joint activities 200

4.4 Explorations 200

5 Liaison 200

6 Output documents and Resolutions of 3DGC 201

6.1 Part 5 Reference Software 201

6.2 Part 16 Animation Framework eXtension (AFX) 201

6.3 Part 25 3DGM 201

6.4 Part 27 3DG Conformance 201

7 Establishment of 3DG Ad-Hoc Groups 202

8 Closing of the Meeting 202

Report of 92nd meeting