57
unicameral legislature, with no elected representation whatsoever, which makes it
even poorer than the previous one.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, given General Khan's apparent aims to remain in power
and govern at his will, this constitution made no provision for separation of powers
or a system of checks and balances. Although
it was disguised as federal,
democratic and civilian rule, nevertheless, the entire
system was in fact an
authoritarian one that revolved around the personality of General Khan.
235
In this
structure and under this constitution, recourse to the doctrine of state necessity
was inevitable: the 1962 constitution was suspended, and martial law imposed in
1969 by General Yahya, although this action was never
challenged in or by the
judiciary.
The East Pakistan crisis escalated and resulted in the Indo-Pakistan war of 1971
which, in its turn, resulted in the secession of East Pakistan. The reason given by
the government of East Pakistan for its secession was the disparity of representation
in the design of the earlier constitutions of Pakistan.
236
The Awami League party
from East Pakistan province secured 160 seats in the National Assembly and PPP
from West Pakistan won 81 seats and yet the leader of the Awami League party was
barred from taking the office and PPP leader Bhutto was supported for the
premiership.
237
This evidence speaks for itself that this phase was
the most unfortunate with
respect to the key factors being used for analysis. There was no equal
representation, no separation of powers, no checks and balance and, above all, the
constitution was General Khan's own product designed
to protect his interests
rather than serve as a real constitution for the country. The secession was not only
a necessity but also inevitable. Interestingly, Pakistan itself was created by seceding
from India so that it could exercise equal representation and freedom from imperial
rule.
235
Lawrence Ziring,
Pakistan in the Twentieth Century: A Political History (OUP 1997) 271.
236
Ved P. Nanda, 'Self-Determination in International Law--The Tragic Tale of Two Cities--Islamabad
(West Pakistan) and Dacca (East Pakistan)' (1972) 66(2) American Journal of International Law 321.
237
ibid.